A Slice of Perfection: The Top Pizzeria in Every State

41/50 Previous Next

© Dough Trader Pizza Company

South Dakota: Dough Trader Pizza Company

In Spearfish, South Dakota, Dough Trader Pizza Company mixes nostalgia with novelty, operating out of a remodeled 1950s Tastee Freez diner building. The retro setting (complete with an outdoor patio fire pit) creates a great atmosphere for enjoying their sourdough-crust pizzas, whether you choose to dine in or take a box to go. Fan-favorite pies here include the whimsically named Scarborough Fair — loaded with marinara, sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers, and lots of cheese — and the Dear Lucille, an Alfredo-based pie topped with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, and cheese. The combination of a unique venue and delicious pizzas makes Dough Trader a cherished find in the Black Hills region, welcoming dine-in and takeout pizza lovers alike.